For cooks looking for an oven-based alternative to a countertop fryer, this Gotham Steel air fryer reviews pick pairs a raised mesh basket with a solid catch pan.
Its 12-inch round format is designed for air-fry, bake, roast, and reheat routines, with fit and usable surface area worth checking against your oven before buying.
Gotham Steel Tray Review Summary
The quick verdict

13,000+ ratings
Read Amazon ReviewsGotham Steel Crisper Tray
A practical fit for cooks who want a compact two-piece tray to crisp, bake, roast, or reheat food in an oven or convection oven.
- Two-piece set with an elevated mesh basket and a solid tray beneath it.
- Round copper-colored basket and tray; the product title identifies a 12-inch size, while the detailed description gives 13.12 inches, so check the product dimensions before purchase.
- Aluminum core with Gotham Steel titanium-and-ceramic nonstick coating.
- Designed for oven air-fry, bake, roast, and reheat settings, including convection ovens.
Pros
- Raised mesh basket supports circulation around food while the solid pan catches drips.
- Its two-piece design can serve several oven cooking tasks.
Consider before buying
- The description gives two different diameter figures, so confirm the current dimensions and usable cooking area before ordering.
- A round tray can be less space-efficient than a rectangular pan, depending on your oven rack and the shape of the food you cook.
Read the full review summary
The Gotham Steel Crisper Tray combines a copper-colored mesh basket and a solid tray so food can sit above drippings and crumbs while air circulates around it.
Its aluminum core and titanium-and-ceramic nonstick coating give the set a versatile role for oven air-frying as well as baking, roasting, and reheating.
This setup is best suited to someone who wants a compact, reusable oven accessory rather than another countertop appliance.
The round footprint may work well for smaller batches and limited oven space, but buyers should confirm the tray's dimensions against their rack and cooking plans; a single round surface may be less convenient for larger or multiple portions.
The buying factors
Gotham Steel Tray Scorecard
Editorial scores reflect listed features and buyer fit; they are not laboratory measurements or customer ratings.
Cooking versatility
The basket-and-pan design is described for air-frying, baking, roasting, and reheating.
Air circulation design
The elevated mesh basket leaves space beneath food for air to circulate around it.
Drip and crumb control
A solid pan beneath the basket is intended to collect grease and crumbs.
Cleaning convenience
The nonstick coating supports food release, and the set is described as dishwasher safe.
Oven fit flexibility
The compact round format is intended for many standard racks and some smaller convection ovens, though measuring your own oven remains useful.
Material and coating details
The aluminum core and titanium-and-ceramic coating are clearly described, along with exclusions for PTHE, PFOA, and PFOS.
Key Features and Specifications of Gotham Steel Tray
- Two-piece set with an elevated mesh basket and a solid tray beneath it.
- Round copper-colored basket and tray; the product title identifies a 12-inch size, while the detailed description gives 13.12 inches, so check the product dimensions before purchase.
- Aluminum core with Gotham Steel titanium-and-ceramic nonstick coating.
- Designed for oven air-fry, bake, roast, and reheat settings, including convection ovens.
- The lower tray catches grease and crumbs that pass through the basket.
- Dishwasher-safe construction and a coating intended to help food release.
Pros and Cons of Gotham Steel Tray
Pros
- Raised mesh basket supports circulation around food while the solid pan catches drips.
- Its two-piece design can serve several oven cooking tasks.
- Nonstick coating and dishwasher-safe construction can simplify routine cleanup.
- Compact round shape is intended to fit many standard oven racks and some smaller convection ovens.
Consider before buying
- The description gives two different diameter figures, so confirm the current dimensions and usable cooking area before ordering.
- A round tray can be less space-efficient than a rectangular pan, depending on your oven rack and the shape of the food you cook.
- The set depends on an oven or convection oven with suitable space; buyers seeking a standalone countertop fryer should compare appliance options.
Who Should Buy Gotham Steel Tray?
Good fit
Consider this tray if you already use an oven's air-fry or convection setting and want a raised basket with a pan underneath.
That layout makes sense for foods that benefit from air exposure while leaving grease and crumbs collected below, and it can also handle baking, roasting, and reheating.
Before purchasing, measure the oven rack and compare the tray's footprint with the portions you expect to cook.
The product information lists both 12 inches in the title and 13.12 inches in its size details, so checking the exact current dimensions is especially useful for a snug oven or smaller convection unit.
Who should skip it
Skip this format if you need a large surface for cooking several portions in one layer or a dedicated countertop appliance. The round shape and oven-based design may not fit those priorities as well.
If your main goal is outdoor grilling, choose a grill basket made for that setting rather than an oven crisper tray.
How the Gotham Steel Tray Fits an Oven Air-Frying Routine
Raised basket, catch pan
The mesh basket sits above a solid tray, allowing air to move around the food while grease and crumbs collect underneath.
This arrangement keeps food separate from the drippings during cooking and gives the set a clear two-part purpose: the basket holds the ingredients, and the pan catches what falls through.
A multi-use oven accessory
The product is presented for air-frying, baking, roasting, and reheating.
That range can be useful for buyers who want one compact accessory to handle several oven tasks, though the design still depends on a compatible oven and enough room around the tray for the cooking method being used.
Coating and cleanup
The aluminum core has a titanium-and-ceramic nonstick coating in a copper finish.
The coating is intended to ease food release, and the set is described as dishwasher safe; following any care directions supplied with the product can help buyers maintain the cooking surface over time.
Measure before choosing
The title and detailed size information do not match: one gives a 12-inch round size and the other gives 13.12 inches.
Since oven-rack width, neighboring cookware, and portion size all affect whether a round tray is practical, verify the current measurements before relying on the stated fit.
Alternatives to Gotham Steel Tray
Grill Baskets alternative

700+ ratings
Read Amazon ReviewsCave Tools Vegetable Grill Basket
Choose Gotham Steel for oven cooking with a separate catch pan; consider Cave Tools if you want a handled basket designed to sit over an outdoor grill and prefer its rectangular stainless-steel form.
- The Cave Tools basket is a rectangular stainless-steel grill pan measuring 13.8 by 11.9 by 3 inches, with a curved handle and dishwasher-safe construction.
- The Gotham Steel set is designed for oven air-frying and includes a solid drip tray beneath its mesh basket.
Grill Baskets alternative

200+ ratings
Read Amazon ReviewsKona Smoker & Grill Basket
Pick Gotham Steel for an oven-based tray-and-basket combination. The Kona better suits someone who wants a mesh accessory for grilling or cold smoking and does not need a solid pan underneath.
- The Kona is a 12-by-12-inch nonstick mesh basket for outdoor grilling or cold smoking, designed to keep smaller foods from falling through grill grates.
- The Gotham Steel tray is intended for oven air-fry, bake, roast, and reheat settings.
Is Gotham Steel Tray Worth It?
The Gotham Steel Crisper Tray is worth considering if you want a compact oven accessory that combines a raised mesh basket with a grease-catching pan.
Its range across air-frying, baking, roasting, and reheating gives it practical flexibility, and the nonstick surface plus dishwasher-safe construction should appeal to cooks who value easier cleanup.
Check the exact diameter and oven fit before ordering, since the supplied product details give two different size figures.
If that footprint matches your rack and portions, this is a sensible option for oven-based crisping; if you need more capacity or a standalone fryer, look for a different format.
Your review at a glance

13,000+ ratings
Read Amazon ReviewsGotham Steel Crisper Tray
A practical fit for cooks who want a compact two-piece tray to crisp, bake, roast, or reheat food in an oven or convection oven.
- Two-piece set with an elevated mesh basket and a solid tray beneath it.
- Round copper-colored basket and tray; the product title identifies a 12-inch size, while the detailed description gives 13.12 inches, so check the product dimensions before purchase.
- Aluminum core with Gotham Steel titanium-and-ceramic nonstick coating.
- Designed for oven air-fry, bake, roast, and reheat settings, including convection ovens.